Legislation Details

File #: 26-2406    Version: 1
Type: Consent Items Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 11/4/2026 In control: Budget Board
On agenda: 11/16/2026 Final action:
Title: Discussion and possible action regarding Presentation by HUB International regarding current services, future feasibility and strategic possibilities of transitioning to a self-insured model, and an update on recent changes and premium adjustments to the Health Choice program. Caitlin, representing HUB, presented a proposal to move Cleveland County’s employee health insurance from Health Choice to a Blue Cross Blue Shield program, with a potential July 1 implementation date to align with the county’s fiscal year. The initial proposal included a PPO and a high-deductible health plan, paired with a medical expense reimbursement arrangement using the Difference Card. Under the proposed PPO, the first $2,000 in medical expenses would be covered, and employees’ annual out-of-pocket exposure would be reduced from $8,300 to $4,600. The presenter compared the current most commonly enrolled plan’s $818 rate with the proposed $595 rate and estimated approximately $220,000 in annual savings base...
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.

Title

Discussion and possible action regarding Presentation by HUB International regarding current services, future feasibility and strategic possibilities of transitioning to a self-insured model, and an update on recent changes and premium adjustments to the Health Choice program.

 

Caitlin, representing HUB, presented a proposal to move Cleveland County’s employee health insurance from Health Choice to a Blue Cross Blue Shield program, with a potential July 1 implementation date to align with the county’s fiscal year. The initial proposal included a PPO and a high-deductible health plan, paired with a medical expense reimbursement arrangement using the Difference Card. Under the proposed PPO, the first $2,000 in medical expenses would be covered, and employees’ annual out-of-pocket exposure would be reduced from $8,300 to $4,600. The presenter compared the current most commonly enrolled plan’s $818 rate with the proposed $595 rate and estimated approximately $220,000 in annual savings based on available data and stated assumptions.

HUB proposed retaining premium savings in a health reserve to support future benefits and potentially allow a transition to self-funding. The presenter outlined improved access to claims data, monthly reporting, employee assistance with billing and coverage issues, and continued coordination with Classen Urgent Care. Members requested further analysis of clinic utilization, costs, and how those services would coordinate with the proposed insurance coverage.

Members raised concerns about pharmacy benefit managers, claims denials, provider networks, future premium increases, broker compensation, and the county’s financial exposure. Caitlin stated that the quoted rates included a 5% broker commission and that other carriers and compensation arrangements could be evaluated. Members requested a list of counties and municipalities using similar programs for reference. Prior efforts to establish a self-funded county plan were also reviewed, including difficulties obtaining sufficient claims data and reinsurance quotes.

Discussion emphasized employee satisfaction with existing coverage, the county’s current financial obligations, and the importance of evaluating the proposal carefully. Members expressed interest in potential long-term savings that could be reinvested in employees but stressed the need to assess fiscal impact, employee affordability, and long-term sustainability before making a decision. The presenter explained that lower starting premiums could reduce the dollar impact of future rate increases.

Members requested revised proposals that more closely match the three current Health Choice options, two PPOs and one high-deductible plan-to provide a clearer comparison. Concerns included employees’ ability to pay the proposed $4,600 out-of-pocket amount if a major medical expense occurred early in the year. Caitlin agreed to prepare comparable plan designs for the next discussion. Employee education and opportunities to verify provider participation and prescription coverage were discussed as essential parts of any transition.

During the employee benefits update, Rod reported that Caitlin had presented the same information to the Health Benefits Committee. Members were encouraged to submit questions to Rod for consolidation and forwarding to Caitlin.

No action taken.

Body

Approve